2006
- Joey Cheek, USOC Featured Honoree
- Lea Plarski, CTSA Lifetime Achievement Award
- Philip Barr & Lauren Clary, NCAA
- John Smoltz, MLB
- Teresa Clark & Brandon Cole, NAIA
- Grant Hill, NBA
- Adam Van Houten, NFHS
- Joshua Harter & Jim Johnson, NFHS
- Patrick Lepper, NJCAA
- Taj McWilliams-Franklin, WNBA
- Bill Byrne & Texas A&M University, NACDA
- Pat Hewitt, NASPE
- Lou Brock, Cardinals Award
- Isaac Bruce, Rams Award
- Hollis Thomas, Hometown Hero Award
2005
- Torry Holt, NFL
- Danny Gathings, Chanda Gunn & the Mesa State Football Team, NCAA
- Edgar Martinez, MLB
- Jim Kessler & Amanda Larsen, NAIA
- P.J. Brown, NBA
- Jamie Vest & Shane Laurie, NFHS
- Doug Weight, NHL
- Kayla Shaul, NJCAA,
- Paul Hamm, USOC
- Teresa Edwards, WNBA
- Wood Selig & Tim Van Alstine, NACDA
- Daniel Gould, Ph.D., NASPE
2004
- Eric Montalvo & Kristen Zaleski, NCAA
- Jamie Moyer, MLB
- Jessica Stollings, NAIA
- Ray Allen, NBA
- Rachel Butler, NFHS
- Darren Woodson, NFL
- Marty Turco, NHL
- Theresa Berry, NJCAA
- Michelle Kwan, USOC
- Edna Campbell, WNBA
- Vince Dooley, NACDA
- Jay Coakley, NASPE
2003
- Paul Moore & University at Buffalo Women’s Soccer Team, NCAA
- Jim Thome, MLB
- Jessica Lenderman, NAIA
- Bob Lanier, NBA
- Revae Green & Tyler Yonge, NFHS
- Shelton Quarles, NFL
- Adam Graves, NHL
- Melanie Mendrop, NJCAA
- Apolo Anton Ohno, USOC
- Jennifer Gillom, WNBA
- Andy Geiger, NACDA
- Jody Brylinsky, NASPE
2002
- Jeffrey A. Steele & Heather Weinhold, NCAA
- Curt Schilling, MLB
- Jodi Henderson, NAIA
- Steve Smith, NBA
- Brian Hartley & Devin Reed, NFHS
- Jerome Bettis, NFL
- Brian Mullen, NHL
- Jermaine Harris, NJCAA
- Vonetta Flowers, USOC
- Sue Wicks, WNBA
- Donald Marsh & Velma Pruett, Stay in Bounds
2001
- George Audu, Safiya L. Ingram & Lindsay Morton, NCAA
- Al Leiter, MLB
- Luke Anderson, NAIA
- Samuel Perkins, NBA
- Robyn Michelle Detty & Christoper Ryan Thomas, NFHS
- James Flanigan, NFL
- Stan Mikita, NHL
- Mindy K. Madewell, NJCAA
- Rulon Gardner, USOC
- Suzie McConnell Serio, WNBA
- John Byers, Gregg A. Hiland & Lori J. Satterfield, Stay in Bounds
2000
- Allison Beightol, NCAA
- Tony Gwynn, MLB
- Jessie Garrett, NAIA
- Hersey Hawkins, NBA
- Jennifer Arrington & Matthew Simmons, NFHS
- Will Shields, NFL
- Paul Stewart, NHL
- Larry Scheller, NJCAA
- Michelle A. Akers & Esther Kim, USOC
- Dawn Staley, WNBA
1999
- Allison Beightol & Jarrett Erwin, NCAA
- Sammy Sosa, MLB
- Rebecca “Becca” Whittle, NAIA
- Avery Johnson, NBA
- Marco Binion & Sheree Riley, NFHS
- Frank Sanders, NFL
- Ron Francis & William “Willie” O’Ree, NHL
- Sarah Wood, NJCAA
- Jackie Joyner-Kersee, USOC
- Suzie McConnell Serio, WNBA